Have something to say?

Tell us how we could make the product more useful to you.

Can't copy & paste saved playbook from one trading position to another

Please add the feature to be able to copy every checked boxes from my playbook rules of one strategy to other postions: For example: I entered a trade on EURUSD with multiple positions and I already marked everything that I did right or wrong from my rules, choose my mood, confidence etc, wrote my key lessons down and now I want to copy everything to another position “trade” because it’s literally identical to the previous position. It would be even better to be able after copying everything to choose to which positions I want to apply it as well so it gets applied even quicker, than copy & pasting it to every position if there are ten positions at once. Thank you!

VelvetOrder about 1 month ago

Add automated calculator as a whole section and add variables to change specific things about the strategy to see how good or bad it would perform

Hey, dear MyPnL suppprt! I read that somewhere should be an automated calculator (all kind of calculators used in Forex, like position size calculator) in MyPnL, but I can’t seem to find it. I also would love to have the possibility to choose either between “(Lot for Forex) size” or in % Risk how much should be risked per Trade and how much I would lose and win, once the entry, TP and SL is set. This could be used anywhere around MyPnL. Maybe like an own section or whole Pop-Up but for that a visualization update would be needed first. If I’m not wrong I already requested once the feature to see how much my performance would change, if there would be something like an AI that would analyse trades from a specific time period, strategy, symbols(assets) by just changing the risk from the one that was made to another risk percentage. For example: There are 100-2000 trades done I made x amount profit in total but let’s assume I traded time by time with different % per trade and I wanna know how much my stats would change if all trades were made on the same risk in % per trade. Would my total performance be better or worse, more stable or unstable. Or vice versa I traded the whole time fixed with 3% per trade and I want to experiment what risk could I choose at maximum before I would blow the whole account with the specific trading system. Maybe go up till 9-10% or more how fast things would change. Also a filter would be nice to have to use it maybe only for a specific symbol (f.e. only EURUSD) or maybe letting the AI or a mathematical function calculating how much the performance would change if you change the Risk Reward Ratio. So basically being able to change variables with filters to see how good certain things would perform. These are one of the features I really want and need. I would love to have them. Please let me know if it’s possible to do. I’d be very glad about it

VelvetOrder about 1 month ago

Automatically add the "-" (Loss) when you enter where the SL would be

When I journal backtesting trades I would have got a loss but on the manual entry it’s marked as a win just because when I add the SL in the settings there no “-” so it would be still a win. So before I click on “Close” trade I have to manually check how much profit/loss I would have made, copy it then write a “-” if it’s a loss and then paste the PnL. I would love to be able that it will be automatically adopted and taken over once the Exit Price it written down. I saw in the classic form there is actually the automatically calculated PnL but Forex pairs are marked as physical currencies (stocks) and a lot gets wrong by that. Here’s where it should be marked as -19.1 already. If I would copy this 19.1$ even tho it’s a loss and go to “close” the trade and paste it there and wrote down the same price as marked in the screenshot (1.09030) it would be marked as a win if I don’t add the “-” symbol to it. Of course there can be SL wins as well when you move to SL into profits but based on the price it still wouldn’t make sense. In this trade the entry price was 1.08648 (1,08648) on EURUSD Also on Forex pairs prices are not recognized by MyPnL correctly, so it gives out an error message when you write for example: 1,06925 so you instead you’d have to write it with dots instead: 1.06925 which is completely wrong. Thank you!

VelvetOrder about 1 month ago

Add feature to automatically calculate PnL on "open" trades based on time/date and lot size

Hey, I would like to have the feature in the section “Manual Entry” that the PnL gets automatically calculated based on the data that is given from the manually opened position (date/time, asset, lot size (for forex) so for example I would see how much I would have made in the past in some trades. Actually this needs to be functional in the backtesting feature, but since it’s not fixed yet that would be an alternative feature to see how good my system would perform Because right now it’s only possible to open positions but they don’t show any automatatically calculated PnL and I would need to manually calculate how much the profit/loss would be.

VelvetOrder about 1 month ago

Make it possible to write down your strategy/system checked by AI

Hey, I would love to have the feature to be able to write down a whole strategy or even trading system which transforms into having check boxes for confirmations hosted by AI. So it’s not the usual playbook anymore. But the key feature would be that the AI would check everything afterwards (or even before you take a trade) based on your entries or the price where you would approximately enter to see if it is/was really your strategy and if all minimum entry signals based on the analysis were meet. It could show where you made mistakes or that it’s not your strategy or indeed it is/was a perfect or good entry. And if not it would tell you where to improve. It also memorizes your mistakes and saves how often you did trade correctly so you can see what you’re doing consistently wrong (of course that would most likely be a loss trade but there could be even win trades that wouldn’t be based on the strategy or system). That would be very unique To be honest I don’t know how realistic this would be to make but I know for sure that with that feature it would definetely make MyPnL worth so much more. Requirements would be of course to fix all other issues first before taking this step right here and improve everything else. But this feature could really make it worth to buy the highest subscription.

VelvetOrder about 2 months ago

Completed

App needs lots of improvement to its import and calculation systems still before its usable.

Hello, Lifetime premium member here. I was very excited about this app when i first found it, but sadly i am STILL unable to utilize it effectively. Quite frankly, i purchased my membership specifically for the ability to auto import my trades. Otherwise, there are many many free alternatives that basically do everything other than the AI features, completely free. For clarity that means that i haven’t and wont be doing any manual entry testing. There have been major improvements to the app recently with the addition of scaling in and out of positions, so I’ve decided to return and continue testing. Testing Conditions Base currency CAD. (used for deposits) Trading mostly in USD. (some forex transactions come through with other currencies) Broker = IBKR All tests cross referenced with other journaling software and broker statements. Findings Still no auto import for IBKR. CSV upload is tedious, but acceptable. hopefully auto import is coming in the future! CSV values not coming through correctly. I’m unsure if the system is trying to calculate the difference between currencies, but lots of the values are incorrect and seem to be off anywhere from 20-30% give or take. Some days don’t even show up at all. There are also discrepancies on the amount of trades taken and win/loss ratios. No need to look deeper if foundational values are off. For reference the exact same CSV imports directly into other paid journaling software fine. The calculations are off as well. On some of the trades that have imported correctly, the PnL is just simply not correct. leading to every single daily/weekly/monthly calculation to be incorrect. MyPnl needs the ability to auto detect trade currency if it does not already have it. again, currency values are off. At current condition, i could not and would not be able to recommend it to anyone i know in good faith. App is simply unreliable in its current state. Will wait for future updates before I test any further.

ThisGuyIsBmaids about 2 months ago

2